A category manager forecasted demand weekly by pasting last year's sales next to 'gut feel' columns. Peaks meant stockouts; lulls meant writedowns.
The manual process worked acceptably for top sellers, where the manager's intuition was genuinely good, and badly for the long tail, which was too large to think about SKU by SKU.
Promotions and seasonality were handled by memory. If the person who ran last year's campaign had left, the demand spike was a surprise for the second time.
Category totals and SKU-level plans never agreed, so finance planned against one number and the warehouse ordered against another.